Was Petra the Sacred City of Early Islam? A Critical Geographical Analysis of Dan Gibson’s Argument from the Battle of the Trench
Abstract
Dan Gibson is a proponent of the revisionist theory of Hagarism, according to which Petra, an ancient city in northern Arabia (present-day Jordan), rather than Makkah, was the original sacred city of Islam. He has presented various arguments to support this theory, one of which is based on the construction of a trench on the northern side of Madinah during the Battle of the Trench (5 AH/627 CE). Gibson argues that the northern location of the trench indicates that the Quraysh approached Madinah from Petra rather than Makkah, which lies to its south. This study critically examines his argument in the light of the geographical features of Madinah, its natural defensive barriers, and the historical circumstances of the battle. It explains that the eastern, western, and southern sides of Madinah were protected by rocky lava fields and gardens, while the northern side was relatively open and vulnerable to enemy attacks. Therefore, the trench was constructed on the northern side for military and defensive reasons, not because the enemy had come from Petra. The study also examines the participation of different Arabian tribes in the battle and the Qur'anic account of the Confederate forces, which confirms that the enemy approached Madinah from different directions. Furthermore, the Battle of Badr challenges Gibson’s claim that the Quraysh always attacked Madinah from the north. The study concludes that the location of the trench does not provide reliable historical or geographical evidence for identifying Petra, rather than Makkah, as the original sacred city of Islam.
